BLOGS:RECIPESASKJUSTIN'S BLOG Register | Log In | Shopping Cart 0

PRODUCTS > More > Sweets > Caramel > 

View Larger Image

Brooklyn Butterscotch Sauce

1 - 12 jars

Starting at $18

  • Includes Ground Shipping
    • All perishable products (such as meat or seafood) are sent with gel packs via
      either Fedex Priority or Fedex Standard overnight. Almost all non-perishable
      items (such as dried mushrooms or dried peppers) are sent via FedEx Ground
      or UPS Ground, which takes 2-7 business days for delivery. A few items
      are shipped via regular mail. The shipping method for each item is noted on
      each item page.

      Items that ship via Ground can be upgraded to overnight shipping (for a fee)
      by contacting us immediately after placing your order.


  • Product Info
  • Storage
  • Recipes & Tips
  • Reviews


7.75oz Jars


Hand Made in Small Batches
Preservative Free


Brooklyn, NY

Butterscotch sauce has an even richer flavor than caramel sauce because it contains molasses.  This may very well be the best you’ve ever tasted – rich and sweet with the occasional crystal of caramelized sugar for crunch.  Meticulous care goes into producing Brooklyn Butterscotch Sauce and it shows in every decadent mouthful.

Spoonable makes their sauces by hand in very small batches – generally as small as 12 jars at a time!  The butter used is top quality European-style butter, prized by chefs for its higher fat content and richer flavor.

This butterscotch sauce was a silver finalist for the National Association for the Specialty Food Trade’s (NASFT) 2012 sofi award.

Ingredients: Sugar, cream (milk), butter, cane syrup, molasses, sea salt, vanilla.

Storage: Store unopened Brooklyn Butterscotch Sauce in a cool, dark place.  Refrigerate after opening.

This sauce contains no added stabilizers and may separate.  To reintegrate, give it a stir before using.

To re-warm butterscotch sauce for use, either remove the lid and briefly microwave the jar, or scoop out the amount of caramel you want and reheat it in a bowl balanced over a pot of simmering water.

Shelf Life: One year.

Drizzle Brooklyn Butterscotch sauce over waffles (especially sprinkled with almonds), cakes or cupcakes (especially chocolate), fruit or ice cream.  Put a little on the spoon you use to stir your coffee or tea to add a little decadence.

You can also just sneak a spoonful as a quick, swoon-inducing pick-me-up.

Dessert Recipes

Product Reviews
Score: 0

Submit Your Review


Sesame Caramel Sauce
1 - 12 jars
Starting at$21
Includes Ground Shipping

Salted Caramel Sauce
1 - 12 jars
Starting at$21
Includes Ground Shipping

Organic Vanilla Coconut Milk Caramels
1 - 10 boxes
Starting at$16
Includes Ground Shipping

Organic Coffee Coconut Caramels
1 - 10 boxes
Starting at$16
Includes Ground Shipping